How Well do Lucy Hale, Shay Mitchell & Sasha Pieterse Know their PLL Co-Stars?

PLL actresses Lucy Hale, Shay Mitchell and Sasha Pieterse played a game testing how well they know their fellow Pretty Little Liars cast mates. At the TCA winter press tour, Xfinity pulled tweets from the PLL cast. Then Xfinity asked Lucy Hale, Shay Mitchell and Sasha Pieterse to guess who said it.

Credit: Disney/ABC Television Group, Creative Commons

First up was this tweet: “Dear @tsa I, too, have never seen as dangerous as chia seed pudding. I’m pretty sure you just stole my breakfast for yourself.”

Shay Mitchell guessed it was Troian Bellisario. The tweet initially threw Lucy Hale. “That doesn’t make sense. I have no idea what that means,” she said. Lucy also guessed it was Troian. Lucy and Shay were both correct. “I knew it! Only she would do that,” Lucy said.

Dear @tsa I, too, have never seen anything as dangerous as chia seed pudding. I'm pretty sure you just stole my breakfast for yourself. 🙄

— Troian (@SleepintheGardn) October 3, 2016

Tweet #2: “And for something a little less controversial … here is me as a child holding a goat and me as an adult with a goat.”

Shay Mitchell immediately knew it was Lucy Hale’s tweet, since she knew Lucy had a pet zoo in her garage for one of her birthdays. (Check out photos from Lucy Hale’s birthday party). Sasha Pieterse also immediately knew it was Lucy’s tweet.

And for something a little less controversial...here is me as a child with a goat and me as an adult with a goat. pic.twitter.com/eWQd30lExf

— Lucy Hale (@lucyhale) June 18, 2016

Tweet #3: “Can’t. Stop. Eating. Popcorn.”

Sasha Pieterse thought the tweet was either from Lucy Hale or Ashley Benson. Lucy told Sasha that she doesn’t eat a lot of popcorn, so Sasha changed her answer to Ashley or Shay. Lucy Hale also guessed it was Shay, which turned out to be the correct answer.

Can't. Stop. Eating. Popcorn.

— Shay Mitchell (@shaymitch) December 7, 2016

Tweet #4: “#throwback to when I almost ate your face”.

This was a hard one for all the PLL actresses. Sasha and Lucy first guessed Ian Harding. Sasha cracked up as Lucy started naming all the PLL cast members, including herself. The last name they guessed, Ashley Benson, turned out to be the right one.

Shay Mitchell also struggled with this one. She actually thought she tweeted it the time she act a macaroon of Ashley Benson’s face.

Tweet #5: “You guys my birthday is like SUPER popular! Like Regina George level popular.”

Shay Mitchell immediately knew it was Ashley Benson’s tweet, since Mean Girls is her favorite movie.

You guys my birthday is SUPER popular! Like Regina George level popular. https://t.co/dEScSzFZYz

— Ashley Benson (@AshBenzo) December 29, 2016

Watch the video below:

How well does @PLLTVSeries's @shaymitch, @LucyHale, & @SashaaPieterse know their fellow cast members? WATCH! #TCA2017 #PLL pic.twitter.com/tIHb1U78jI

— XFINITY (@XFINITY) January 15, 2017

How well do you know the PLL cast? Were you able to guess which actresses were behind the tweets?